Roof Replacement Cincinnati

Advantage roofers were absolutely great and the right company to replace my roof. They sent pictures of every step in the process. The staff were very friendly. The owner came to introduce himself and made sure I was satisfied with the job. I can't say enough about this company. I would recommend this company 100%.

Advantage Roofing exceeded our expectations and were able to get us worked into their schedule in a very timely. All work and cleanup was completed very efficiently in one day.

I would recommend Advantage Roofing to anyone! The experience has been seamless! From the quoting process to the installation everything is done with excellence and care! Thank you for taking care of our home!

Advantage Roofing, I highly recommend, they earned a five-star rating. Scott and Jonna were very professional, and I liked doing business them. The work crew were on time and did the job in one day. I was impressed by the way they protected the landscape and windows. They cleaned up after the job and it looked better than when they started. Tim the owner came out and checked on the job. How often does the owner come to the job site and ask how things are going. Thank you, Tim, Scott and Jonna, you made getting a new roof easy.

Advantage roofing was an amazing company to work with; polar opposites from the roofing company we dealt with in September that took our deposit and ghosted us. From the sales person, Scott, to the office contact Jonna, all the way down to their project manager, Jeff, the communication was amazing! We ran into more problems during our installation that were unseen at the time of our estimate and they handled everything with so much professionalism. We cannot praise them enough and have already referred 2 of our friends to them! Thank you all again so much!

Advantage Roofing was wonderful to deal with. Not only did the cost come in lower than I was anticipating but they also took very good care of us. When the normal gutter aprons didn’t fit they had custom gutter aprons made at their own cost and installed them on my house. All along the way they communicate very well and set expectations very well. We are very happy with the whole process. The crews are very efficient and do high quality work.

Advantage Roofing was one of 2 companies that we had submit proposals for replacing our 20-year-old shingles. They provided several options for us to consider. They replaced the shingles, not just putting on a second layer. They were careful about protecting our shrubs, did an excellent job, and cleaned everything up. Our large flowerpots on the deck were returned to their exact location. The team explained what they would be doing and answered any questions promptly. The customer service was outstanding. Tim, an owner of the company, stopped by himself to check whether we had any issues. I would certainly recommend Advantage Roofing as a good resource for other's roofing needs.

Could not be happier! The communication on scheduling the project and adjusting the date with weather was great! Manny and Jeff communicated with me every step of the way and kept me aware of the progress. Jeff came back the next day to ensure everything was installed properly and checked the yard to confirm no nails or debris was left behind inadvertently. Great job all around!

Advantage Roofing will only settle for a 100% customer satisfaction. The employees work with complete dedicated effort. I’m so satisfied with the roof replacements on the church and school buildings where I’m a member of that I’m having Advantage Roofing replace the roof on my home.

Roofers were on time. Controlled the debris. Job finished on time. Clean up was good. Magnet nails very good. Very happy with my new roof!

Advantage Roofing did an amazing job. They were fast, efficient, and they communicated every step of the way. I would recommend them time and time again.

Amazing service, great price! The crew was the hardest-working group of guys we've ever seen. They did the entire job (removing two layers of old shingles, repairing one spot of water damage, and installing all new roof on a 2700-ft house with a complex roof line) in one day. They even left our place cleaner than when they arrived!

I had a great experience from start to finish. I had my roof replacement and gutter replacement due to hail damage. Scott Gay from Advantage Roofing worked with me and my insurance company for the replacement. The whole process went very smoothly and I am in Love with my roof! I now have 50 yr. roof with a Class 3 Impact rating against Hail. Highly recommend...

I would recommend Advantage roofing to anyone! They have now installed 3 roofs for my family (1 on my first house and 2 for my parents) and each time the experience has been phenomenal! From the quoting process to the installation everything is done with excellence and care! Thank you for taking care of our home and delivering excellent service as always!

One of the better contractors I’ve had to our house in general. Really responsive, very competitive pricing, and high quality work. They came through every step of the way

They came out and fixed my issue thanks

Advantage just replaced my roof and skylights and I could not be happier. Communication was outstanding every step of the way. Everyone I dealt with was knowledgeable and professional. The installation went quickly and smoothly, and the cleanup afterwards was immaculate. Price was reasonable. I can't imagine there's a better roofing company out there.

Scott was extremely helpful in dealing with a very difficult insurance adjuster and after months of struggles we were able to get her to agree to cover the costs for replacing the roof.

If I could offer 10 stars, I would! Advantage Roofing recently replaced the roof to my husband’s and my home. This included new decking, new shingles and new vents. Tim Mallory (owner) and the entire team at Advantage Roofing provided professional and knowledgeable service from beginning to end. Scott assessed our needs and gave us an estimate that was fair and competitive. Jonna kept us up to date with scheduling and Jeff informed us throughout the day regarding the installment process itself. When the big day arrived, the roofers arrived on time, were polite and respectful towards us and our property and demonstrated excellent workmanship skills. We loved our beautiful new roof immediately!! But we were disappointed and upset to learn that the venting system we had anticipated was not the one that was installed. Not only did Tim Mallory phone us immediately to address our concern and assure us that our 100% satisfaction was what mattered most, but he came over to explain everything that went into the decision making process regarding the roof vents. It turns out, our very, very old house is structured in a way that prevented the venting system we were hoping for to work. Tim Mallory and Advantage Roofing are comprised of a team of professionals who really care about their clients first and foremost, the products they use, the quality of the workmanship, and every aspect of the service they provide! Well done, Advantage Roofing!! And thank you! We are deeply grateful for your honesty and sincerity and integrity. We are truly thrilled with our new roof!

We had a top-notch experience from start to finish with Advantage Roofing. Their project manager was extremely helpful and informative all the way through the process. Scheduling communication was great with our variable November weather. The installation team did a great job with installation and clean-up. Job well done!

Advantage Roofing sales person Scott was personal person who explained in detail how the process worked. We did our research and believed the product they used on our roof was 1 of the better products on the market. I've always done my own roofs in the past, but I'm getting older and this was just more than I wanted to handle. Since I've done several roofs in the past I know when someone is on the up and up. I felt Advantage Roofing out of the 5 quotes was the best company to work with. Once the decision was made, they did what they said they would do. They showed up on time cared about the quality.They cleaned up and when they left you would not have never known we just had a roof installed. Advantage Roofing was not the cheapest but so far I am happy with the results.

Roof looks great, clean-up was well done. Very happy with Advantage Roofing and would recommend them to anyone needing repair or installation on their roof.

We learned about Advantage Roofing from my wife's co-worker. I wanted to get several estimates for such a large investment. I was very impressed with Joel who did our assessment and provided the estimate. The estimate was very competitive, but I was more impressed with the team starting with Joel, then once we decided to go with Advantage, Jonna, Tim and the crew have been great they are professional and very efficient. I am very happy with our choice, and our new roof looks great. The follow-up inspection was also a nice touch and look forward to seeing Tim next year when he comes back to make sure all is well. You can't go wrong with Advantage Roofing!

First time investing in a new roof. Advantage helped to guide me along the process with great communication throughout and patiently responding to my questions. They consistently and timely did what they said they would and everyone I interfaced with..Scott, Jonna, Tim, Jeff and the crew were all very easy to work with. It was a big leap of faith for me to jump from another reputable roofing company that I have used for ~20 years over to Advantage, but I have not second guessed my decision!

The crew was very professional. The workmanship was great. I was kept up to date on the progress several times.

Great job all around! I would highly recommend.

Advantage Roofing is wonderful, know what they're doing & efficient. The crew was here early in the day, finished by 6pm & cleaned everything up completely. Someone came out the next day to get any nails that were left on the ground & did an excellent job. Highly recommend Advantage Roofing.

My husband and I recently replaced our roof, using Advantage Roofing. Our experience from the beginning assessment, to scheduling, to the final walk through was exceptional! Everyone was highly professional and very understanding of our extensive situation. Our roof was removed and replaced with appropriate repairs made, all in one day. We highly recommend Advantage Roofing to anyone in the area looking for an outstanding respectable company that puts their customers first.

Absolutely a pleasure to do business with! They did exactly what they said they would! Showed up exactly when they said they would and completed the project in one day! They left the property just like it was before they started. I would highly recommend Advantage Roofing. Tim & Johnna are absolutely fantastic to work with! Call them today.

I will do my best to detail everything I can think of. Hopefully it is of some help and generates business for their local roofing company. How it started: A recent windstorm hit in June 2025. Random roofers were regularly soliciting in our neighborhood after noting missing shingles. They would then always promise a free roof (NEVER believe random solicitors). Feazel stopped at least 3 times, all in violation of local soliciting ordinances. I knew this was going to be pricey. I reached out to Advantage about our missing shingles because they had done several minor repairs over the last decade. They inspected the roof. They never oversold or overpromised. If anything, Advantage's assessment was reasonably cautious. They said I had a good chance of getting partial claim covered (based on the damage and insurance provider we have). They also said the shingle was likely discontinued, and that it might get it fully covered, depending on the policy details. Other roofing estimates all but guaranteed us a free roof out of the gate. I stuck with Joel at Advantage, mostly because a) he didn't overpromise, b) he gave a great presentation of their product, and c) the estimate was comparable to others. Insurance Claim: Joel and Team handled all the insurance claim documentation and even showed up for the insurance inspection. They made the process as simple as possible. We were initially granted a partial claim for the damaged section, just as Joel predicted. Joel then pursued the discontinued shingle angle with our insurance, and we managed to get a second claim approved! Advantage matched the insurance estimate (~$30k for full replacement), and the process of replacement began. The product: The used Certainteed shingles and materials. Based on the research I did online, they are a premium quality manufacturer. Installation: It took ~16 hours for their crew to remove the old roof and install the new one, as it had ~13 roof planes on steep angles. The crew was friendly and respectful. Considering they filled an entire long dumpster with debris, they did a fantastic job with cleanup (don't expect perfection from any roof job cleanup folks, especially if you have a lot of landscaping). They even came out a separate time with magnets to double check our yard for nails. Inspection: They do send someone out for a post-install inspection. I still had some questions after the inspector visited, so they sent out a member of the crew (Manny) to address those concerns. Final Visit: Tim Mallory, the owner, even came out just to get me comfortable with everything, as there is just a lot of roof there (and I am not a roofing expert). He pointed out where the gutter aprons were, explained the situation with drip edges and our custom trim that was already present, and just did a fantastic job of getting me comfortable with the decisions made. Depreciation Recovery: Once everything was completed, Jonna (office manager) sent the required documentation to our insurance agent to get the remaining claim released for payment. One Year Inspection: Advantage will also come out in One Year, free of charge, to insure everything still looks good, which is a nice touch. Overall: I would not hesitate to use their services again. What impressed me most was how they seemed to go out of their way to address any questions/concerns that came up. My wife and I are already discussing replacing the gutters in the rear, as they are badly stained and installed at a greater slope than they should be. Advantage Roofing will definitely be #1 on my call list for future estimates. Unrelated: Safeco, our insurance provider, was both fair and responsive. I cannot recommend them enough!

From the RFP response to the punchlist, Joel, Tim, and the installers were on top of their game. The installers worked as a team to protect our surroundings during tear off and to provide new roofing materials. Communication from the office and the field personnel was on going throughout the project and change orders were verbally and visually submitted. In short, I recommend Advantage Roofing.

From the first call and quote to install, I was treated well and provided with all the information. Installation went smoothly and clean up was great. Everyone was professional. Communication and customer service was exceptional. My high quality, new roof looks amazing and the process was easy. I highly recommend Advantage Roofing.

I had a very positive experience from the first contact with the salesman to the final inspection by the owner! The crew did an outstanding job from the moment they arrived 'til they cleaned up the area hours later. The roof looks great and is high quality and the price was exactly as quoted even tho some wood had to be replaced. I highly recommend this firm!

Great service. Full information provided to us from start to finish . Professional follow up. We would highly recommend them.

We had a very good experience with Advantage roofing. During our roofing job, the owner of the company came out at least a half dozen times, and even took pictures of the work as it was underway ! We also had gutters removed, and new ones installed. Great experience, would definitely recommend !!

We had an outstanding experience with Advantage Roofing and can't recommend them highly enough! From start to finish, the entire team was professional, efficient, and a pleasure to work with. Special thanks to Scott Gay, who was the first to inspect our roof. He stepped in during a very frustrating situation that began with our insurance and another contractor. Scott gave us the clarity, direction, and reassurance we desperately needed. After our first meeting with him, we knew we wanted to work with Advantage Roofing - and they absolutely delivered. Jonna was excellent with communication throughout the process, keeping everything on track and ensuring we were always in the loop. Jeff also did a great job updating us on each step of the roof replacement and inspection. Manny and the entire crew worked quickly, cleaned up thoroughly, and the new roof looks fantastic. We felt comfortable and confident with Advantage Roofing the entire way through. They were actually recommended to us, and now we’re happy to pay it forward - we’ll recommend them to anyone needing roofing services. This company truly went above and beyond!

Had Advantage give a quote on replacing my roof. They were very helpful, clearly explained the process, and the price was fair. They really seem to value the homeowners experience and you don't always feel that way with construction. Would definitely recommend them to anyone!

I had a wonderful experience with Advantage Roofing. After hiring another contractor that dropped the ball, Advantage picked it up! They stepped up and worked with my insurance company and got my claim covered. They let me know where we were in the process, and then let me know when I could expect the work to be complete. Once they started the work, I got pictures at every step when they were putting my roof on. It was great! I couldn't recommend them enough. If you need someone who is professional, and has one of the best (and quickest) roofing crews I've ever seen, these are your guys.

Great communication from the start - Scott Gay is awesome. Follow up before, during and after install was impressive. Job completed efficiently and awesome cleanup.

Tim (owner) and the crew were fantastic. Complete roof tear down and replacement (including all new plywood) and when they left you wouldn't even know they had been here. Beautiful roof and great company to work with. Highly, Highly recommend!

The entire Advantage Roofing team was great to work with. Jonna, Manny, Joel, Jeff, and Tim provided outstanding customer service and continuous updates. The roof looks great!

Great experience from getting a quote to installation, to one year post installation inspection. The owner of the company came to perform the 1 year inspection and even brought a 1 year birthday bundt cake! Professional, knowledgeable, and friendly. Highly recommended.

We just love advantage roofing! We have used them more than once for different projects! Each time they made the experience easy to navigate! They did a great job of explaining everything and making our house beautiful! They are a wonderful family owned business and would definitely use them again in the future and recommend them to anyone needing new gutters or a new roof!

My cousin had used them to replace their roof and referred us to use them. They communicated very well through the whole process and they were very friendly and helpful. They gave a free inspection and repair estimate and their pricing ended up being far more reasonable than the pricing of others we had checked. Our roof looks great now and we would recommend anyone to use them for their roofing needs.

Our experience with Advantage Roofing could not have been better. Scott was our initial contact and explained the estimate very thoroughly- he was great to work with. The scheduling was easy, during the install of the new roof, we had frequent communication with Tim who sent pictures of the progress and answered any questions. The crew was on time, install was within the time period quoted, clean up was complete and Tim came back the next day to inspect everything. 5 STARS!!

Advantage roofing has met and exceeded my expectations. From the estimate to picking out colors, to scheduling and installation. Everything went seamless. Tim the owner was on site the whole time during installation and even pitched in and helped the install team. You don’t get customer service like this. Everyone there cares about doing an excellent job and complete customer satisfaction. The job was completed by experienced installers that knew exactly what had to be done. My yard was even cleaner when they finished. Not one nail or roof debris were left behind. The lifetime warranty is unheard of these days and I know they will stick behind their work. I highly recommend this family owned business. They are an A+ in my opinion. Thank you Tim, Jonna and Joel for taking care of my roof.

Advantage Roofing recently put a new roof on our home and did a wonderful job. I would recommend this company so highly. From the initial consult to the final construction, they were so professional and kind. Mr. Mallory was there throughout the day checking in himself and with pictures to follow the progress. They cleaned up our properly as if they weren’t ever there. We are so very pleased and recommend them highly. Thank you Advantage Roofing!! The Briggs family.

Great customer service. Kept us informed as the work progressed. Workers were efficient and cleaned the property when done. I highly recommend for your roofing needs.

Advantage Roofing was top notch from start to finish. Joel was quick to respond to all my questions and sent me an estimate right away. I had reached out to two other roof companies and they were both not responsive like Joel at Advantage Roofing. Jonna setup our install date and was great communicating all steps in the parking with relaying pictures from the project. Tim, the owner came out for the final inspection. Everyone from Advantage Roofing was professional, friendly, and responsive. We are going to use them again in the coming weeks for our other home that we just purchased. I can’t recommend them enough.

Thank you for turning our roofing problems into a good experience. Tim (the owner) impressed us with his punctuality. He explained everything that was going to be done. He answered all of our questions and found a remedy for our gutter problems. His crew was very professional and respectful. Jonna helped us work with our insurance company, on the day of the installation she sent us pictures of the progress that was happening on our roof. When we had a small problem later, someone came out almost immediately to rememdy the situation. They even remembered us after the job was done, letting us know that they were thankful for our business. We are repeat customers and we are happy to reccomend Advantage Roofing. Sue and Jerry W., West Chester, OH

I recently had my home’s roof replaced by Advantage Roofing, and I can confidently say that Tim Mallory (owner) and his crew are the gold standard in residential roofing. From the very first consultation to the final cleanup, every step of the process was handled with professionalism, transparency, and top-tier craftsmanship. Scott Gray the project manager arrived promptly for the initial inspection and provided a detailed assessment, explaining everything in a clear and honest way—no sales pressure, just solid information and expert advice. What really stood out was his commitment to helping me make the best decision for my home. Once the work began, the crew was punctual, respectful, and extremely efficient. They took great care to protect my landscaping and the surrounding areas of my property and left everything spotless when the job was done. The roof itself looks phenomenal—beautifully installed with high-quality materials, and I’ve already had neighbors asking who did the work. What impressed me most was the communication and attention to detail. Tim kept me informed every step of the way, and their responsiveness was unmatched. It’s clear the people at Advantage Roofing genuinely care about their customers and the homes they work on. If you’re a homeowner looking for a roofing company you can trust, Advantage Roofing is the one to call. They deliver superior results, outstanding service, and real peace of mind. I highly recommend them! Five star plus rating! Sincerely, Kimberly G.

Wow! I am so impressed with my roof installation that happened today. They were on time, efficient, professional, and the project turned out great. Communication leading up to the project with Jonna was consistent & responsive. The owner even came out to the project to oversee, answer questions and thank me for the business. Total project took 5 hours to install and looks great! Would highly recommend!

From start to finish our experience was exceptional. They helped us pick out the color of our roof with samples they had and even placed them on the roof to give us an idea of the finished look. Everything went smoothly. I would highly recommend Advantage Roofing if you're looking to replace your roof.

We had our roof replace by Advantage Roofing. They did an excellent job and were very concerned about safety. I was very impressed by the overhead drone pictures showing progress and areas that needed board replacement. They covered up all of our plants and cleaned up to make sure no nails were left behind. I would highly recommend them for your roofing job.

The whole process was so smooth and easy!! The roof looks great!

Came out right away to give us a quote. Price was good, and they said they would remove all old shingles from roof - the other quotes were only removing "damaged and detached" shingles. Work was done in one day, very professionally. They came out a couple of days later to inspect job with us. We saw a couple of things we didn't like, so they came back a few days later and fixed them. Looks great.

Very professional. Excellent communication from start to finish. Very happy with the roof. Would highly recommend Advantage Roofing

Advantage Roofing excelled in the entire project! From the sales representative Scott, to Jonna in the office to Tim the owner, every person was professional, kind and friendly! The job was completed as scheduled with no complications. Jonna handled the submission to the insurance company and the claim was paid. Definitely recommend going with Advantage Roofing!

I highly recommend Advantage roofing. They did such a fantastic job and were extremely professional and polite. The crew worked so hard and did an exceptional job of cleaning up. The communication throughout the process was excellent. Thank you again to the entire team!

Very professional company. Tim went over everything that they would do in detail. They did a excellent job of cleaning. The follow up was terrific. I would recommend Advantage Roofing to anyone needing a new roof. I got good value for my dollar.